10 Best Nail Pullers of 2021 | Reviews & Buying Guide

Nail pullers are available in a variety of shapes and sizes, and depending on the type of job that you need to get done, it can be difficult to find the right one for your project. While some of them are perfect for working in narrow spaces, there are others that are specifically designed for projects where some clearance space is available.

Some nail pullers also called as cat paws that come with additional features which may come in handy for you. To find out the best nail pullers, check out the below list and the buying guide that follows it. 

Best Nail Pullers

1. Crescent 56 nail puller : Best Product Overall

Crescent 56 nail puller

If you want to pull out  nails without damaging the underlying surface, this is the perfect nail puller for you. The design is more on the traditional side, and the tool works by driving the small head under the nail head into the wood, and then using force to pull the nail out. The one advantage of this model is that you will not have to remove a lot of word when you are pulling the nail out, because the jaws of the puller allow you to drive straight into the wood.

Moreover, the tool also does not bend the nails when you are pulling them out, so if you want to use them again, you can definitely do that. Crescent nail remover can also remove nails that are headless, as the jaws are capable of forming a tight grip on the body of the nail. The product is also available in short and long jaw designs and works brilliantly with flush nails as well. Since the product has been manufactured using a box joint design and the jaw is hardened and tempered, you can also rest assured that it will last you for a very long time – even under tough conditions. 

PROS

CONS

  • Made out of forged alloy box joint

  • This nail puller work great on flush and hard to grip nails

  • Best for craftsmen who work on renovation and remodelling projects

  • The product has a black enamel finish that add durability

  • Some people reported that the jaws were deformed when used on steel nails


2. Stiletto TICLW12 : Best Premium Pick

Stiletto clawbar nail remover

This lightweight nail puller can get any kind of flush or embedded nail out, and it does so without weighing you down. Since the product is made entirely from titanium, it retains the strength and durability of the metal without adding any extra weight. Moreover, it is also lighter and stronger than any of the aluminum nail pullers in the market.

Stiletto TICLW12 Clawbar Titanium Nail Puller also has excellent heat resistance and resists corrosion naturally. It is quite shock absorbing, and you will feel the difference when you are hammering or pulling with this tool, because the impact of the force will be less felt on your hands. The tool comes with a nail exposure as well, which makes it easy to get the teeth of the tool around the nail. It does so by hammering around the nail and carving a divot in the wood around it.

If there is one drawback of this nail remover – it is that it is quite expensive, especially compared to the other nail pullers on this list. Unless you are a working professional who needs something like this on a near daily basis, it might not be worth it for you to invest so much money in a nail puller. 

PROS

CONS

  • Made from lightweight titanium

  • Compared to steel bars, it has less recoil

  • Very comfortable to hold and use

  • Excess force can bend the light titanium


3. Bates nail puller : Best Budget Pick

Bates nail puller

If you want a nail puller for DIY projects, Bates nail puller is the perfect product for you. This 11-inch puller is forged with high carbon steel, which means that it will last you for a very long time without getting damaged. The high carbon steel material is also resistant to rusting. The grip of the nail puller has a soft plastic coating which allows you to establish a firm grip on the tool while you are pulling or prying the nails.

Not only does it allow you to maintain the grip for longer periods of time, it also prevents slipping off the tool from your hand. The plastic coating also prevents damage to the underlying surface when you are using the tool. The claw design of the nail puller makes it easy for the user to remove nails, both short and long, with relative ease. You can also use it for removing nails that have a damaged head by not damaging the underlying would too much. It is just long enough to create the right torque without creating too much stress on your hands. 

PROS

CONS

  • Forged from high quality carbon steel

  • For better usability, the handle has soft plastic grip

  • Hard to pry the jaws open


Other Great Picks

4. Estwing Nail Puller

Estwing nail puller

If you are looking for an inexpensive nail puller that you will only use occasionally, this is the right product for you. It combines strength and longevity with an affordable price and excellent performance. The entire body of Estwing nail puller forged in a single piece, which means that there are no weak spots where the tool might break. Indeed, this near polar will last you for years or even decades because of its sturdy design and solid manufacturing. It also has rounded heads on both of the sides which increases the torque and gives you extra force to remove the toughest of nails.

This nail puller has a narrow body, which makes it easy to get to nails in even tight spaces. The precision thin claw will allow you to reach confined places and males in hard to access areas. The claw is also designed in such a way that you can even remove headless nails without damaging the wood too much. If there is 1 downside of this tool, it would be that it does not perform very well with long nails. 

PROS

CONS

  • Forged out of one piece making the puller more durable

  • Rounded head gives extra torque and gives you leverage

  • Ability to remove headless nails

  • Sometimes, you may experience inconsistent grinding


5. Crescent Nail Puller

Crescent nail-puller

If you are concerned about the space in your workshop or tool bag, this is the perfect flyer for you because it has a very compact body. However, just because it has a smaller package, it does not mean that it is not powerful enough. The plier works on the same principle as the larger models on this list. All you have to do is grip the head or the body of the exposed nail and rotate the pliers to get it out of the wood. Although you are likely to get some tear out, this method will not damage the underlying wood too much.

However, the main drawback of this tool is that because of its small stature, you will not get as much leverage with it as some of the other, bigger tools. Since the handles are quite small, you do have to use extra force to get the nail out of the wood. This can be an especially big problem for people who have wrist problems. Moreover, the pliers also tend to bend the nails when removing them. This may not be a problem for most people, but if you are planning on using the nails again for a restoration project with original parts, this may not be the best option for you. 

PROS

CONS

  • Best in class nail puller that can be used for multiple purposes

  • Comes with forged steel head and handles

  • The puller has rubber grips for better control

  • Made in china product so quality control can be issue


6. Dead on tools EX9CL Nail Puller

Dead on tools nail puller

The Dead on Tools EX9CL nail puller is manufactured in a traditional style, while still maintaining simplicity. Moreover, it is also one of the most affordable nail pullers out there. The tool also has a circular saw range on the side as well, so if you are someone who uses a circular saw on a regular basis, you will get some extra use out of this tool. Since the product is quite long and thin, it does not need a lot of space to do its job and therefore, it works brilliantly in tight spaces.

However, it does have some flaws that you need to know before you decide to buy it. The most important one is that the claws on both sides of the tool are odd sized. This means that it may be a little bit tricky to remove standard sized nails if they do not fit well into the claws. Moreover, it is very difficult to get a good grip on smaller nails with this model – so you’ll struggle to get them out too. Pulling headless nails is completely impossible, as is removing pins, stapes, or small brads. 

PROS

CONS

  • Tool has easy grip making it easy to operate

  • Can’t be used for very delicate projects


7. Stanley nail puller

Stanley nail puller

This nail puller may be small in size, but that does not mean that it compromises on performance. You can pull all types of nails from the wood with this tool without worrying about anything. The body of the puller is forged of high carbon spring steel, which means that it will last you for a very long time. It is also quite strong, and very well suited for heavy duty jobs. Because the body is also tempered and heat treated, you can rest assured that it will continue doing its job excellently for a very long period of time.

The edges of this player are also polished, so that they can provide you precise penetration when you are pulling nails. On the other, striking side of the bar, the surface is flat which allows you to use the claws for driving deeper into the wood and reach nails that are embedded. Additionally, this tool has an ergonomic grip which is quite comfortable even with prolonged usage. The grip also works as a shock absorber and insulates you transferred forces when pulling nails. 

PROS

CONS

  • The nail remover has been tempered for added safety

  • Faster in operation compared to other nail pullers

  • To increase durability the tool has been heat treated

  • The build quality of material is soft


8. Shark nail puller

Shark nail puller

The shark nail puller is made of hardened steel alloy which gives it the ability to function precisely and accurately in harsh environments and last for quite a long period of time. Moreover, the hardened steel has also been tempered. This ensures that the claws of the nail puller will not bend or chip, even then you are pulling out embedded nails or tough nails. The tool is 11 inches in length and it is just big enough to give you leverage by not exerting any extra efforts.

Indeed, you can even pull out small and medium sized nails with this tool without any issues. The head of the nail puller has also been rounded to give you more torque and reduce the work required for pulling the toughest of nails. The claws are also sharpened, which allows you to get to headless nails and nails with relative ease.

On top of all this, this nail remover is extremely compact, so it will fit into your tool bag and won’t take too much space. The one drawback of this product is that it does not have a rubber grip, which may make it difficult to be used for extended periods of time. 

PROS

CONS

  • Has the ability to pull embedded, headless or rusted nails

  • The nail puller has really well made design

  • Made in china so quality can be an issue


9. Vaughan & bushnell dalluge da bar nail puller

Vaughan & bushnell dalluge da bar nail puller

Just looking at this nail puller gives you the idea that it has been made with durability and precision in mind. The tool is made of tempered and forged steel. This makes it solid, sturdy, and reliable for years to come. In fact, it is strong enough to handle heavy-duty projects, and on top of that, it is light enough for you to carry it without weighing down your tool bag. The nail puller is 14 inches in length and this gives the user just enough leverage.

You can even pull out long nails with this tool with zero difficulty, because the edges have been rounded off. It also increases comfort when using the tool and reduces pressure on your hands when pulling out embedded nails. The claws of the puller are slender, so that you can fit it under embedded nails and not damaging the wood too much.

This makes it the ideal tool if you are working on a recycling project and want to reuse the wood. The chrome finish off the bar also prevents corrosion and makes it resistant to chipping. This makes this nail puller the best suited tool for professional usage. 

PROS

CONS

  • Build quality is enough to sustain heavy tasks

  • The design is thin and light making it very easy to use

  • The thin body may bend under excess pressure


10. Air locker AP700 Nail Puller

Air locker nail puller

This air locker AP700 nail puller is not a traditional device and it has been designed in such a way that it pushes out the nails and not causing damage to the wood. The device uses air pressure to push the nails out from the other side, and it is capable of removing 10 to 20-gauge nails without any difficulty. It has a full cast aluminum body which is quite lightweight, so you don’t have to worry about adding extra baggage to your tool bag.

The metal body also ensures that the product will last me for a very long time and that it can withstand the roughest of workplace conditions. The handle of the nail color is also rubberized, so that you have a firm and easy grip while you are using it. The ergonomically designed nose is thin and elongated so that it can fit even in narrow places and push the nails out with zero difficulties.

You can use this device for pulling out nails, both from soft and hard woods, because it is powerful enough to handle the latter with relative ease. The one drawback of this product is that sometimes the nails may get stuck inside the plunger of the nail puller. 

PROS

CONS

  • Best in class build quality

  • Removes nails of all types

  • Motor is prone to damages


Buyers guide 

Here are the most important factors worth considering when buying a nail puller: 

The power

That is the most important factor and you need to determine how much nail cooling power you need before buying a tool. Most of the products featured have the ability to remove embedded nails and dig out headless nails from the wood, while there are others that only work if there is some space between the head of the nail and the wood.

You also need to keep in mind that a longer handle means that you have to apply less force to get the nail out. So choose the right product keeping these factors in mind.

Compactness

Depending on the areas where you will be working, you need to decide how small or big of a nail puller you need. If you are going to work within areas where there is enough clearance, get a nail puller with a long handle so that you have to apply less force. But if you’re going to walk in tighter spaces, get something smaller that can fit into these spaces.

The handle

You want a nail puller that has a strong and substantial metal handle with rubber coverage. This allows you to use the tool for prolonged periods of time without it sticking to your hands. It will also give you a stronger grip and will make it easier as well as safer for you to apply the force when you’re pulling off an embedded nail. 

Working surface considerations

The best puller would be the one that can get the nail out without damaging the wood underneath. However, this may not be possible as there are very few nail pullers that can give you a completely clean working surface. But you can minimize the damage by choosing a nail puller that has round and smooth under diggers. You can also use pullers that use pressurized air to remove the nails, instead of traditional plier type tools. 

Types of diggers

When you are pulling out a nail, the board has to reach the head of the nail and clamp underneath it with the tip off the digger. To get maximum results with minimum damage to the wood underneath, you should choose a nail puller that has narrow tips which can reach the furthest underneath the nail head to pull it out. At the same time, it should also be hard and resistant to chipping in order to maintain maximum functionality. 


Conclusion

Depending on your unique requirements and the kind of job that you need to get done, you can choose anyone out of our list of the best nail pullers. Having said that, reliable brands like crescent, stiletto, and estwing have tried and tested nail pullers which you cannot go wrong with. However, before making your purchase, make sure that you have analyzed the requirements of your project and only then make the decision for best results. 

The Edge Cutter is reader-supported website. When you buy through links on our website, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Leave a Comment