Rack And Pinion Vs Ball Screw | Which system is more accurate for a CNC router?

The traditional CNC routers operated by a Rack and Pinion system. However, the expensive metalworking and aerospace mills were driven by Ball Screw systems. That being said, the technology used in driving systems has evolved over time, enabling the companies to employ the Ball Screw system into the CNC machine industry to manufacture the routers, mills, etc. more precisely and  reliably. 

Now you might wonder what makes the Ball Screw so expensive yet better than the Rack and Pinion system? Well, a number of reasons are there to choose the Ball Screw over a Rack and Pinion system. I have picked the top three reasonable attributes to compare the above two driving systems in a CNC router. Let’s check in!

  1. Unparalleled Durability and Accuracy 

The Ball Screw driving system is more efficient than Rack and Pinion and requires less torque. The former one has lower friction than the latter and hence, operates at lower temperatures.

  1. Upgraded Levels of Wear and Tear 

Ball Screw driving systems provide much improved levels of wear and tear. This system comprises a sealed bearing containing a number of recirculating ball bearings uniformly spaced and continually lubricated as the bearing drives through a designed channel. The channel is cleaned using wipers beforehand to remove dust and debris from entering the inner bearing.

On the other hand, the Rack and Pinion driving system includes a gear and track both connecting together without any lubrication (metal to metal contact). But, make sure to apply grease to the track manually which generally gets contaminated with dirt, dust or debris from material cutting. This decreases the lubrication and accelerates the wear and tear of the gear/track. 

With time, it wears down the gear and its track, and the gap between the gear teeth further increases (hence, increasing backlash), which in turn affects the overall precision of your table. This is because of the fact that the Rack and Pinion have to stop on the exact same points (tooth) time and again. Whereas, in case of a Ball Screw system, it’s design is such that the Ball Screw has unlimited contact points for all the ball bearings to stop at some point. Therefore, the frequency of wear and tear is much less in a Ball Screw driving system, allowing it a tighter accuracy to maintain for longer.

  1. Enhanced Overall Precision

The overall accuracy of a Ball Screw design is the third reason for choosing it over a Rack and Pinion system, which is otherwise a risky choice. You cannot expect to acquire tolerance or resolution with a gear system, which a ball bearing system can produce. Many of the Rack and gear systems that advertise  the Rack and Pinion systems cannot be physically maintained as the gears don’t see the tolerances. 

Not even the most expensive cum upgraded Rack and Pinion systems worth  over $100,000 can provide the same tolerances as that of a Ball Screw system. That is the reason that most industrial CNC routers that you see have their Z axis driven by a Ball Screw. When cutting tolerances and depth matter, then the professionals only rely upon the best, i.e. the Ball Screw design technology.

The Recirculating ball bearing systems are utilized in every Linear Guide Rail systems and is the most relied technology found in high-end metalworking milling to CNC routers to high-end aerospace centers. If your CNC router incorporates the same technology in it, then any sort of routing work can be as easily as  accurately as possible with such an advanced system. If you are looking for better routing force, higher speed followed by a smoother system operation and improved accuracy, then a Ball Screw mounted CNC router is what you need. 

Unlike a Rack and Pinion system, the Ball Screw drive’s large contact pads on each axis evenly distribute the cut forces all over the frame design, bearings, and guide rails. This prevents the risks of backlash that is otherwise needed in a Rack and Pinion drive to turn into fine cutting edges with better finish. With a Ball Screw assembly in your CNC router, you can prevent wobbling and inaccuracy that most Rack and Pinions drives lead to. 

The issues mentioned here are caused due to uneven wearing of the gears on both sides (front and back) of your CNC router, which changes the device tolerance, hence affecting its accuracy. But the story is just the opposite with a Ball Screw technology integrated CNC router which doesn’t affect the cutting, debris, and work tolerances.

The Edge Cutter is reader-supported website. When you buy through links on our website, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Leave a Comment