SCROLL SAW VS JIGSAW : Which is Right Tool For Your Needs

A scroll saw is a bulky, stationary tool which has an integrated table to it, and upon which the workpiece is placed to cut through the delicate blade. On the other hand, a jigsaw is a handheld tool which is brought on the surface of the work material to cut it rather than doing vice versa. This type of saw is more common on the market and is more efficient cum practical compared to a scroll saw. Jigsaw has a wider range of applications, however, that does not make a scroll saw any less of its virtue. A scroll saw has its need in almost any professional woodworking shop. Plus, they have a number of benefits besides being able to do tasks that any other tool may not do.

Scroll Saw Vs Jigsaw: Their Applications

SCROLL SAW

A scroll saws is a specialized woodworking tool, mainly used to make delicate and intricate patterns on any workpiece. But the thickness of that material should not be more than 2 inches. The tiny, thin blade of a scroll saw lets you to comfortably turn and handle the workpiece on the circular dime. The saw makes cuts at 90-degree and wavy, sharp angles.A scroll saw is a quiet device, which is its plus point to use it in prolonged cutting jobs. Moreover, this type of saw does not generate much dust, and it is relatively safer. If you are a beginner in woodworking, you will surely find it a fun activity to work with this saw. Things which are not possible to do but a jigsaw are the 3D fractal and pierce cuts (that is, making cuts from inside out), intarsia (collage-type cutting pattern), and marquetry. All these types of wood arts require super-delicate cutting, thereby leaving room for creativity and artistry. The setback of a scroll saw is that it consumes much space as they are big in size. Plus, they do not have any practical requirements in the workshops of the enthusiasts or hobbyists. These specialty tools are limited to the hands of highly skilled, pro-grade woodcrafters only. On the contrary, the jigsaw is a one-stop device, the jack of all trades, for any woodworker. Other than the cordless drill, table and/or circular saw, etc., the scroll saw is another such tool which is widely used in a woodshop. For any type of cutting work, maximum chances are that you will get the work done by a jigsaw. The only setback of a jigsaw (if you consider it so) is that it is a free-hand crude tool, which does not deliver cuts as finer and precise as a scroll saw does. A jigsaw is a perfect device for cutting plastic, metal, foam, wood, PVC, and more. Other than that, it can make curves and circles, or any odd pattern cuts which are not at all possible to accomplish by using a circular or table saw.

Scroll Saw or Jigsaw: Which One is a Better Choice?

If you are looking for a saw just to meet your DIY woodworking hobbies, or to add just a new tool to your workshop inventory, go for a jigsaw by all means. It is of high utility value as you can achieve any practical requirement with a jigsaw. If you are a creative person, who likes to try out different artistic skills with the workpiece, then go for a scroll saw. A DIY crafter with such interests should also avail this type of tool to make attractive masterpieces out of wood, metal or other materials. Note: Before buying a scroll saw, make sure you have enough space for its installation in your workshop.

Looking to Buy One? Here Are Some Top Picks

A couple of top scroll saws and jigsaws are listed below to help you with a successful model purchase (if you are looking for one):

Top Scroll Saws:

1. DeWalt DW788 20” Variable Speed

DeWalt DW788 20” Variable Speed

DeWalt DW788 Scroll Saw is an expensive choice to invest in followed by a guaranteed quality. This power tool is incredibly cleaner in its cutting operation. You can carve any simpler to delicate and intricate design on the workpiece. Not to mention, this scroll saw delivers a second-to-none cutting quality.

2. Delta Power Tools 40-694 20” Scroll Saw

Delta Power Tools 40-694 20” Scroll Saw

Delta Power Tools 40-694 Scroll Saw is again a costly option. Despite its high price, the tool is widely purchased in the market for its simplicity and user-friendliness. The quality is top-notch and ergonomically designed to make it easy for both the beginners and non-professionals to enjoy using it, if the cost is no bar.

Top Jigsaws:

1. Bosch JS470E Jigsaw

Bosch JS470E Jigsaw

Bosch JS470E Jigsaw is a high quality cutting hands-free tool that comes within an affordable budget. Overall, it is simply, yet incredibly user-convenient device with easy blade-changing system. The variable speed control operation of the saw is what makes this jigsaw model the most-sought among the woodcrafters.

2. DeWalt DCS331M1 20V MAX Cordless Jigsaw

DeWalt DCS331M1 20V MAX Cordless Jigsaw

DeWalt DCS331M1 Jigsaw is a bit expensive compared to its counterparts. However, it is a value for the money in terms of portability, handling, and convenience. Moreover, being cordless adds another virtue to this tool. The device is powered by a 20V MAX battery and will leave you working for hours with that device without a pause, on just a single charge. You get 3 bevel degree options (15°, 30°, and 45°), 4 variable speed settings, and a dust blower to keep a cleaner and visible line of sight during the cutting application.

Conclusion

A scroll saw or jigsaw, either of them is primarily used for making curved cuts. However, a jigsaw is the most-used one out of the two for its compact size and hands-free portability. Plus, as mentioned above, you can deal with a number of other general applications with a jigsaw compared to a scroll saw. A scroll saw is more likely to deal with minor cutting jobs that require intricacy and less cuts in the project. The art and design making with precise, minor cuts are what you generally do with a scroll saw. On the top of that, a top-notch scroll saw is what makes such cutting tasks easier and convenient. So, both are equally beneficial, provided that you know which one you need for your projects.

The Edge Cutter is reader-supported website. When you buy through links on our website, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Leave a Comment